Notes for Reviewers

NOTES FOR REVIEWERS

1. Guidelines for Reviewers

Before accepting or declining an invitation to review from the DTU Journal of Science and Technology, reviewers should consider the following:

  • Reviewers should accept the invitation only if the manuscript falls within their area of research and they feel able to provide clear, high-quality, and scientifically sound evaluation and comments.

  • If reviewers identify any potential conflict of interest, they are requested to notify the Editorial Office.

  • Reviewers should ensure that they are able to meet the deadline for submitting their comments within the timeframe proposed by the Editorial Office via email (standard review period: 3–4 weeks for an article requiring revisions before publication, and a maximum of 10 days in the following two cases: acceptance for publication or initial rejection).

Note:

  • Reviewers should respond to invitations as soon as possible, as delays may affect the overall publication schedule, regardless of whether they ultimately accept the review invitation.

  • Reviewers’ comments and evaluations assist the Editorial Board in determining whether an article should be published. Reviewers may provide specific comments and recommendations, but should not include detailed requirements concerning writing style, spelling, or manuscript formatting, as these matters will be handled by the Journal’s editorial staff when the manuscript reaches the editorial stage.

  • Reviewers should change the displayed name associated with the Comment and Track Changes functions in Microsoft Word to ensure double-blind peer review (a form of peer review in which reviewers and authors do not know each other’s identities throughout the review process).

2. Providing Reviewer Information

Reviewers are required to provide complete and accurate information (using the form provided in the invitation letter) before undertaking the substantive review of the manuscript.

In cases where reviewers decline an invitation, they are also encouraged to provide information and remain open to opportunities.