Peer Review Process

PEER REVIEW PROCESS

1. Standard Peer Review Process

The anonymized manuscript and the invitation letter will be sent by the Editorial Office to the reviewers via the email system of the DTU Journal of Science and Technology.

Reviewers are expected to carefully evaluate the manuscript and provide comments based on the Journal’s specific criteria. Overall, the peer review focuses on the following five main aspects:

  • Determining the nature of the manuscript: Reassessing whether the manuscript under review is a scientific paper or merely a report presented in the form of an article, or a conventional review article.

  • Assessing the reliability of research data and scientific integrity: Evaluating the reliability of the research data and the scientific integrity of the manuscript, and identifying any potential plagiarism.

  • Assessing the title: Determining whether the title accurately reflects the actual research content of the manuscript.

  • Assessing the structure: Examining whether the structure of the article is logical and scientifically sound and, if not, recommending appropriate revisions.

  • Assessing the content: Focusing on the scientific and academic aspects of the manuscript and specifying any necessary revisions, changes, or additions.

The conclusion of the peer-review stage may be one of the following:

  • The article is of good quality and can be accepted for publication, with no revisions required or only minor revisions to wording and spelling.

  • The article requires revisions to its content and/or structure and should be returned for further peer review before a final decision on acceptance or rejection is made.

After receiving the reviewers’ comments, the author(s) are required to cooperate in revising the manuscript and resubmit it to the Editorial Office for further review until the reviewer reaches a final conclusion: acceptance for publication or rejection.

2. Multiple Rounds of Peer Review

Some articles may require reviewers to conduct at least one or two rounds of review: the first round provides suggestions for necessary revisions, while the second and third rounds assess whether the author(s) have adequately addressed the reviewers’ comments and make a final determination.

Normally, the Editorial Office allows reviewers 7–10 days to complete the first round of review and 2–3 days for each subsequent round after the author(s) have cooperated in making the requested revisions. However, during periods close to publication deadlines, the Editorial Office may request reviewers to expedite the review process to meet the publication schedule. In such cases, reviewers are encouraged to cooperate with the Editorial Office whenever possible; if they are unable to do so, they should notify the Editorial Office accordingly.